AUDIT REVEALS INCOMPETENCE IN OKLAHOMA GOVERNMENT!

 Weekly Opinion Editorial

INCOMPETENCE

by Steve Fair

 

     On Wednesday, Oklahoma State Auditor and Inspector (OSAI) Cindy Byrd released a 200-page performance audit on federal money the state of Oklahoma received in COVID relief funds.  Byrd said that state agencies failed to spend the money as it was designated.  The audit found the money was spent on administrative salaries and personal expenses and not on public assistance as the feds had intended.  Byrd says state taxpayers may possibly be on the hook for up to $200 million.

     Oklahoma received almost $5 billion in federal COVID-19 relief from two major pieces of federal legislation, the CARES Act and the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA). The money was earmarked for the state, local governments, and tribal nations, to fund  a variety of programs and services- Byrd claims the Office of Management and Enterprise Services (OMES) mishandled $22 million dollars designated to help Oklahomans with rental assistance.  The Department of Human Services (DHS) failed to adhere to the guidelines associated with another $63 million of the relief money according to the audit.  Byrd said Oklahoma taxpayers may have to pay back almost $200 million dollars.  Three observations:

     First, Oklahoma taxpayers deserve better.  It is not surprising government bureaucrats blow through taxpayer money.  That is what bureaucrats do, but when they ignore spending guidelines and are not competent to do the job, they should be fired.  At the very least, a bureaucrat should have the necessary ability, knowledge and skill to do the job they are being paid to do.  When they fail, those who are elected and charged with appointing and managing those bureaucrats must be held accountable.  Governor Stitt appointed the directors of the two aforementioned agencies.  He is a lame duck and is term-limited, so voters can just butt a stump.  It appears there will be no repercussion or consequences for the incompetence.    

     Second, OMES is a bloated unnecessary state agency and DHS has always been a money pit.  OMES was created in 2012 when Mary Fallin was governor.  The stated reason, at that time, was to consolidate government services and improve efficiency.  The real reason was to give the weak governorship in the Sooner state more power. Since inception, OMES has been a boondoggle that has resulted in an extra layer of government.  DHS has traditionally had a huge annual budget, fraught with waste, so it's no surprise they couldn't properly administer the relief money.  OMES should be dismantled and DHS retooled.            

     Third, the power of the OSAI needs to be expanded.  The state constitution mandates the OSAI audit county government and state agencies, but performing performance audits must be requested by the governor or the leadership of the legislature.  Most Oklahomans mistakenly believe the state auditor can audit anything/anybody/anytime.  To expand the scope of the OSAI's duties would require a vote of the people, but it's past time to get it done.  A conservative legislator should run a Joint Resolution in the coming session expanding OSAI's duties. 

     Cindy Byrd is an announced candidate for Lt. Governor.  Critics of the audit's findings claim she timed the audit's release to further her 2026 statewide campaign.  Byrd has been further accused of 'spinning' the audit's findings, but there is no evidence that is the case. 

     The job of the auditor is to find fraud and corruption and expose it.  Only the naïve and simple believe Oklahoma state government bureaucrats did the right thing with the COVID relief money.  Clearly, errors were made and those who point errors out shouldn't be attacked- they should be commended.  It remains to be seen if the feds will require taxpayers to pay back the misspent money, but meanwhile at OMES and DHS, it's business as usual.