Sunday, November 22, 2026

Collectivism or voluntary compassion?

 Weekly Opinion Editorial


TO WHOM MUCH IS GIVEN!

by Steve Fair

In Luke 12:48, Jesus tells Peter and the other disciples, “to whom much is given, much is required.” Jesus was teaching the principle God holds people accountable in proportion to the knowledge, authority, and resources entrusted to them.  Blessings like time, talent, and treasure are meant to be used wisely, rather than be wasted or hoarded. 

Socialist often misapply the passage to justify collectivism/socialism.   The classic socialist maxim is, “from each according to his ability, to each according to his need.”  They are not the same thing.  Jesus taught his followers to share their wealth and to love their fellow man, but not a forced state system that takes from the needy and gives to the greedy.

America’s progressive income tax system effectively acts as wealth redistribution, discourages higher productivity and is essentially the same ‘graduated income tax’ system Karl Marx advocated in The Communist Manifesto (1848).  The U.S. system has higher income earners paying the lions share of income tax.  Consider the following: In 2025, the top 1% of wage earners in the U.S. paid 38.4% of all the federal income tax.  The top 5% paid 60% of the total and the top 10% paid 70.5% of all federal income tax.  The top 50% of earners in America paid 96.7% of the total income tax- the bottom 50% just 3.3%. Three statements and three brief observations:

First, the rich pay their fair share.  As evidenced by the above, the more income you earn in America, the more income tax you pay.  Second, the poor pay taxes.  Lower wage earners in America may not pay federal income tax, but they pay social security tax, and state and local taxes. Third, every American is paying taxes.  From fuel tax, sales tax, property tax, state income tax, capital gains tax, excise tax, and other taxes and fees, America has effectively taxed his citizens to death.  Three brief observations:

First, the current progressive federal income tax system is not only unfair, but it discourages ambition.  Why earn more if you simply are working for the government?  A consumption (sales) tax would be fair.  Everyone pays the same percentage when they purchase a good or service.  Second, the federal government is a bloated bureaucracy and its footprint needs to be reduced.  The argument against tax cuts is always the same- government services will be impacted, but when economic times get tough and private industry has layoffs, government workers are never cut.  Government workers seldom have to do more with less.  Third, America’s economic system has evolved from a capitalist system to socialist.  Government has expanded well beyond the original intent of the founders.  17th-century philosopher John Locke argued that legitimate government should be strictly limited and just protect citizens' natural rights—life, liberty, and property.

Jesus’ challenge to Peter and the disciples in Luke was to use their time, talent, and treasure to be a blessing to those laid in their path.  But in no way was Jesus teaching a secular government was to mandate/require citizens to give their assets to the government for redistribution.

No comments: