Weekly Opinion Editorial
CREDIT OR BLAME?
by Steve Fair
As the government
shutdown enters the second month, it appears no end is in sight. President Trump offered concessions to the
Democrats for the ‘dreamers,’ the young illegal immigrants brought to the
country as children, in exchange for funding of a border wall. Thus far, no Congressional Democrat- House or
Senate- has expressed support for Trump’s proposal. The POTUS has vowed to continue the shutdown
until funding is agreed to. Democrat Congressional
leaders have refused to negotiate with the president and vowed to not give in.
First, Democrats
have agreed in the past to most of Trump’s proposals. Fox News delights in showing clips of Speaker
of the House Nancy Pelosi, (D-CA) and Charles Senator Schumer, (D-NY) publicly advocating for border barriers before Trump was president. To a degree, that paints them into a corner.
Second, President
Trump has taken ownership of the shutdown. Unlike the Democrat congressional
leadership, Trump admits his part in the shutdown. According to the Washington Post, that is
translating into the loss of support from Trump’s political base, but there is
little evidence his supporters are abandoning him. One of Trump’s primary campaign promises was
the building of a border wall and to his credit he is trying to deliver on that
promise. The Democrats are committed to
making sure he doesn’t succeed. Like him
or not, the POTUS doesn’t back down from a fight and is not the typical
politician. That has to be unsettling
for career politicos.
Third, Trump’s
proposal on Saturday is eerily similar to one he criticized during the primary
campaign. During the GOP debates, Senator
Marco Rubio, (R-Florida) was a frequent target of the other candidates for his
views on illegal immigration, which included a ‘pathway to citizenship.’ Rubio’s ideas were attacked and Trump was the
primary critic. Just goes to show you
that the theoretical often differs from reality. Governing is more difficult than campaigning.
Fourth, a
shutdown may be an opportunity to prune the federal government. The POTUS has amazing leverage when it comes
to putting the civil service workforce back to work. If Trump wants to really shake things up, he
could hold out for only partial reopening of the government. Clearly, the federal government is bloated
and a workforce reduction in one stroke of a pen would be painful, but it may
be the only way to deal with it. Just
rip the bandage off! The national debt
is out of the control. Pruning
government would be a good thing and while ‘across the board’ is not the ideal
way to do it, it is a way.
The Democrat congressional
leadership and their rank and file have shown remarkable solidarity through the
shutdown. They hope voters in 2020 will blame
President Trump for the shutdown, and give them credit for opposing the wall. That is risky because polls show most U.S.
citizens are very concerned about border security. The POTUS may get more credit than blame.
No comments:
Post a Comment